
This is what my Aunt Prissy had to say about this week’s theme of comfort food: “Cooking is definitely more than just an activity we do to satisfy the need of hunger. It is saying I love you, I’m sorry, Congratulations, you’ll do better next time, I understand.” I couldn’t agree more.
Chicken Pot Pie is a dish I have made often to say exactly those kinds of things; it’s place in the comfort food category has as much to do with the comfort I am giving away by making it as with the comfort I receive from doing so. Whether for a friend who has a new baby, a church pot-luck dinner, new neighbors, or the loss of a loved one, Chicken Pot Pie has been a reliable staple. It’s a safe-enough dish to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters, and kids usually like it too (especially if you cut the carrots into small enough pieces). Also, it goes a long way if you use a whole chicken, and most people I know have only had the frozen kind, so a homemade one is a real treat (sad, I know, but true!).
Different takes on the basic idea of chicken pie abound–Sara Foster and Ina Garten both make a version topped with biscuits, some people use puff pastry, other people use celery or green peas or potatoes or heavy cream. My way is pretty unfussy. When I make it for just us, for dinner, I make this recipe in a black cast-iron skillet, which dirties only one dish if the chicken is cooked already (the dishwasher around here really likes this recipe for that reason alone!) To take somewhere, I double the recipe, cook the filling in my biggest saucepan, and then dump it all in a big casserole. The key to its tasting really, truly homemade, I think, is in the stock, which imparts a richer chicken flavor than plain canned broth (but that works in a pinch too).
I’m going to give you the steps, from stock to finished pie, but I would never do this all in the same day. Usually, when I roast a chicken, I make stock from the carcass and reserve any leftover meat. This pie makes perfect use of both. If you don’t have leftovers from a whole chicken, you can always cook breast meat in water with lemons, garlic, onions, and a carrot, and make a stock that way. However you make your chicken pie, I hope you will serve it to someone who could use a plateful of comfort. In my experience, this does just the trick.
Chicken Skillet Pie
To make stock:
In a roasting pan (I use the same one the chicken was originally roasted in), roast the bones and leftover drippings at 400 degrees for about an hour, until the bones are a deep, dark brown. Scrape everything from the roasting pan into a large stockpot; cover with water. Add a lemon, quartered, an onion, quartered, and a few cloves of garlic. Salt and pepper well. Bring to a boil, and then simmer for a long time (I never time it; I just let it sit all afternoon). Strain the solids and skim off any visible fat. You can keep it refrigerated if you plan to use it soon, or freeze.
To make pie:
1/2 T. butter
1/2 T. olive oil
1 large yellow onion, diced
3 cloves garlic, sliced very thinly
1 cup sliced mushrooms
1 cup diced carrot
1 T. butter
1 T. flour
1 1/2 - 2 cups stock
1 1/2 cups cooked chicken meat, chopped
1 refrigerated pie crust
Preheat the oven to 425 degrees. In a large skillet, heat the oil and butter over medium-low. Add the onions and garlic, and cook until they begin to soften, about 4 minutes. Add the mushrooms and carrots and cook, stirring, until all the vegetables are very, very tender, about 20 minutes. Salt and pepper. Scrape the vegetables to the sides of the skillet, leaving the middle of the skillet open. Add the butter and flour, and mash together quickly to form a paste. Once they have combined, then stir into the vegetables to coat. Add the stock a little at a time to thicken, stirring constantly. You don’t want it to be too thick because it will lose some of its liquid in the oven, but you don’t want a runny pie either. The liquid should begin to coat your spoon. Stir in the chicken and remove from the heat. Cut the pie crust into long strips, laying them on top of the pie in a lattice pattern. (Of course, this is optional; I just think it looks pretty!) Bake for about 35-40 minutes, or until the crust is brown and the filling is bubbly. These quantities can easily be adjusted depending on how much chicken you have and how many people you plan to feed. This recipe easily serves 4.