Oyster Love

The first time my husband saw me eat a raw oyster, I wasn’t sure if our relationship would make it. I have treasured these sea-dwelling delicacies for as long as I can remember. But David? Not so keen on the texture. And, he cringed every time I slid one off of a cracker into my mouth. But oysters are supposed to be so romantic, I said, the ultimate love food. How could we be in love and not enjoy oysters together?

Thankfully, David bravely overcame his oyster-phobia and even enjoys them raw (or so he says) these days. But one of his favorite ways that I fix them is this way: baked under a layer of bread crumbs, butter, and blue cheese.

Because I love them so, we often have oysters on various special occasions. It just so happens that I made these about a month ago, in celebration five years of marriage to the man who has learned to endure many quirky things about me, including my passion for these slippery little mollusks. For that alone, I love him so.

This recipe is adapted from Blue Cheese Oysters in (fittingly enough) Martha Hopkins’ and Randall Lockridge’s aphrodesiac cookbook, Intercourses.

Blue Cheese Oyster Gratin

2 dozen oysters (I buy them already shucked, packed in liquid from my fish market)
4 ounces blue cheese, crumbled
1/2 cup bread crumbs
3 T. butter, softened
Sliced bread (I used sourdough)
2 large cloves garlic, halved

Preheat the oven to 350 degrees; spray a square baking dish with cooking spray. In a small bowl, combine the butter, bread crumbs, and blue cheese. Lay the oysters in a single layer in the bottom of the baking dish. Top evenly with the blue cheese mixture. Bake for about 12-15 minutes, until the bread crumbs are browned and the cheese is soft and melted. Toast the bread slices while the oysters are baking. Rub each side with the cut side of a garlic clove; serve the oyster gratin with the toast.

I served a simple salad on the side: raddicchio, baby lettuce, carrot, halved grapes, and blue cheese crumbles, under a sherry mustard vinaigrette (for which I promise to post a recipe soon; I always forget to measure quantities when I make it!)

9 Responses to “Oyster Love”

  1. Rorie Says:

    Hell yeah. I love oysters, too …. never had them in a gratin but it sounds divine. And with blue cheese? Again, hell yeah.

  2. emily Says:

    I love oysters.The season is oming to a close and I haven’t had my fill.I like them steamed,raw…you name it.

  3. Karina Says:

    Happy Anniversary! Love in the face of quirks is true love.

  4. MM Says:

    That sounds to die for! I do not think I can go out with a guy who hates oysters myself!

  5. Ivonne Says:

    Swoon!

    This recipe is definitely a keeper! Like you, I adore oysters. Adore them!

    I have yet to actually use them at home. I usually go to a local restaurant that I love to have them.

    You’ve inspired me to give them a try at home!

  6. Laura Martone Says:

    When it comes to food, I’m usually a pretty simple gal - much to my husband-the-culinary-master’s chagrin! As for oysters, I usually eat ‘em raw - as simple as it gets - or perhaps fried on a po-boy, but I’d be willing to give this recipe a try in a heartbeat, and I know the hubby (who tolerates the raw kind) would adore it. Blue cheese, bread crumbs, and garlic are some of his favorite ingredients! Thanks for the inspiration.

  7. Jackie Says:

    I’m going to make this as it sounds great. My husband and I both love oysters and eat them quite often. Please tell me what type of blue cheese you use and if you tried different kinds. I would think a milder blue would be best right?

  8. armpit stop sweating Says:

    Greetings from Los angeles! I’m bored at work so I decided to check out your blog on my iphone during lunch break. I enjoy the info you present here and can’t wait to take a look when I get home. I’m shocked at how fast your blog loaded on my cell phone .. I’m not even using WIFI, just 3G .. Anyways, fantastic blog!

  9. sweat shops Says:

    what’s your facebook?

Leave a Reply