Gnocchi, Finally

Every cook must have her proverbial thorn-in-the-side dish. You know, the one you’ve tried and tried and tried again only to fail miserably each time. My most recent thorn has been the little Italian potato dumplings called gnocchi. I once bought premade gnocchi from the grocery, and they were pretty good but really expensive for just potatoes and flour. So I tried to make my own. How hard could it be to bake a few potatoes and combine them with flour? I made a huge, sticky mess, and the dumplings (if you could call them that) tasted gluey and bland. My next attempts, using various recipes, were no different. So I decided to throw in the towel. If we were to eat gnocchi at our house, it would have to come from an expensive plastic package, much to my chagrin.

And then, the lovely and talented Ivonne at Cream Puffs in Venice posted a gnocchi recipe during her Piemontese foods series in honor of the Olympics. She swore it was easy and fool-proof, and her instructions, complete with pictures, looked as if they might end my gnocchi woes.

With some sideline coaching from Ivonne, I’m happy to report that the gnocchi turned out just as she describes: the dough was elastic but not too sticky, and the dumplings floated to the top when they were ready, just as they were supposed to. Mine aren’t quite as pretty as hers; I couldn’t quite get the hang of the fork indentions, but they tasted lovely nonetheless. I tossed the hot dumplings with butter and a combination of fontina and Parmesan cheeses, as Ivonne suggests. To make the meal a bit more substantial and add some color, I topped each serving with a spoonful of chunky oven-roasted tomato sauce. The end result was a delightfully simple and satisfying supper.

Notes: The problem, I discovered, with my earlier gnocchi attempts was that I was using regular baking potatoes that are entirely too starchy. Waxy potatoes make a huge difference! I used Yukon Golds for this recipe. Also, refrigerating the dumplings before adding them to the boiling water also helps a great deal. They hold their shape nicely after having some time to firm up in the fridge. If you’re looking for a fool-proof way to try gnocchi, I urge you to try Ivonne’s recipe. I’m already thinking of variations for my next attempt…

11 Responses to “Gnocchi, Finally”

  1. Darla Says:

    Oh how I admire you! I’ve wanted to make gnocchi since my first trip to Italy 3 years ago and have never gotten the guts up to fail! I will try though and your tips are appreciated.

  2. paula Says:

    Those look incredible! I love gnocchi but they can be tasteless, even in some good Italian restaurants where I’ve ordered them.

  3. Rorie Says:

    I’ve never made gnocchi either - but its one of my favorite Italian meals - I am definitely inspired to try it after your encouraging post. It looks delicious with your oven-roasted tomato sauce!

  4. Ivonne Says:

    Brava! Bravissima!!!

    Jennifer, I am SO PROUD of you! Not only do your gnocchi look gorgeous, but that sauce … woooh! … the sauce is glorious! What a lovely addition. Thanks for giving me some inspiration for the next time I make gnocchi.

    I’m so glad that it worked out for you and that you made the recipe your own. Nothing makes me happier than to see people overcoming the little food obstacles in their way, just as I try daily to overcome mine.

    I’m sure that your household will be enjoying the most magnificent gnocchi from now on!

    My compliments to the gnocchi chef!

  5. emily Says:

    Way to go!

  6. Kady Says:

    How pretty! I love gnocchi, especially fried like hash browns.

  7. heather Says:

    Congrats on your success. I have yet to find my food nemisis yet. I know it is out there, but I just haven’t found it.

  8. Lizzie Says:

    yum… I thought this was blackberry cobbler before I read about it. Haha, oh do I have things to learn about cooking and food. :) I am glad you kept fighting for the gnocchi.

  9. Karina Says:

    Go waxy, eh? Who knew? I tried making gluten-free gnocchi last year and it was a total gummy disaster. Yours [and Ivonne’s] make me want to try again - but it’ll have to wait until we’re moved, then settled…then semi-sane.

    Excellent, Jennifer!

  10. Weekly Dish » Blog Archive » Weekly Menu Says:

    […] Gnocchi with Pesto Tuna with Avocado and Corn Salsa (to follow shortly!) […]

Leave a Reply